Underdogs Struggle in WNBA Playoffs

With Aces star A’ja Wilson snagging her third MVP honors last weekend, the 2024 WNBA Defensive Player of the Year (DPOY) award has now taken centerstage. Both Wilson and Lynx standout Napheesa Collier are frontrunners, sparking heated debates.

Aces coach Hammon speaks out on A’ja Wilson

Last Thursday, Las Vegas head coach Becky Hammon called out ESPN journalists who revealed their 2024 WNBA votes. Notably, Hammon went to bat for players not on her roster, like New York’s Sabrina Ionescu, but particularly took voters to task for giving their DPOY nod to Collier.

“They got the MVP stuff right,” she told the press. “The Defensive Player of the Year? If you have to, as a journalist or a reporter, go down a rabbit hole to find somebody else to be in the conversation, you already have the answer.”

Lynx coach Reeve fires back in support of Napheesa Collier

As the previously scheduled guest on Monday’s episode of Good Game with Sarah Spain, Minnesota head coach Cheryl Reeve was asked if a DPOY vote for Collier “is a vote deserving of anger.”

In response,​ Reeve​ — the 2024 Coach of the Year favorite — explained that while she had not seen Hammon’s press conference, “most people that I talk to think [Collier’s] a unanimous decision.”

“You look at the top three or four defensive teams — in A’ja’s case, can you be the Defensive Player of the Year when your defense isn’t in that?” Reeve continued. “She’s had an incredible year, but she can have MVP and Napheesa Collier is Defensive Player of the Year.”

Who deserves to win WNBA Defensive Player of the Year?

Reigning back-to-back DPOY Wilson, whose 451 rebounds set the WNBA’s new single-season rebound mark this year, has certainly made her case for a threepeat. She led the league in blocks per game, plus recorded a career-high steal rate this season.

Collier, who slightly trails Wilson in rebound and block rate this season, shines in steals, with a per-game average good for second in the league. But it’s the Lynx forward’s ability to defend multiple positions, plus her role in positioning Minnesota as the WNBA’s second-best defense per possession — a measure that sees the Aces claim fifth in the league — that reportedly is giving her the edge with DPOY voters.

Ultimately, the choice between the two stars seems to be about individual prowess versus team contribution. It’s a decision Reeve summed up as simply, “it depends on what you value when you vote.”